Friday, January 11, 2008

Herbs

"What is the cause of XXX ?" asked in the grand round. The XXX could stand for kidney problem, liver problem, confusion, or any nondescript symptom.

"It is herb-induced."

Alas, the crowd march to next bed. What a convenient answer ! Herb has become a rubbish bin: any problem that we cannot explain - or do not have time to explain - we take it as herbs. How often is it proved ?

We know very well that there is not much firm scientific evidence - randomized control trial - on the efficacy of herbs on any medical condition. (This simple fact seems not being recognized by our government and local granting agencies - another excellent example that planned economy always fails.) Nonetheless, there is equally limited amount of evidence on clinical problems caused by herbs - except a few highly characteristic ones.

You may not like herbalists, but it is exactly for that reason you should not attack them by their (lack of) logic and argument.

No comments: